Restoration of the Great Ming: A Tianqi Timeline

1638
387px-%E9%8C%A2%E8%AC%99%E7%9B%8A.jpg

Qian Qianyi (circa 1638)

The Descent Upon Nagasaki sends ripples through the imperial court. On the one hand, Admiral Zheng’s partisans have been riding the high for months. The Admiral is rapturously popular among his followers in Dongshan, obviously, and the city of Luoyang enters a bit of an economic boom, fueled by foreign trade and foreign “trade” (they’re smart enough not to pillage the Spanish or Portuguese, but the Dutch? or anyone else who looks shifty? at this point, that’s fair game).

Less impressed are some of the more somber members of the bureaucracy. Zhou Qiyuan patiently writes another memorial to the throne, explaining how foreign adventurism may have unintentional consequences. His message is read to the emperor and politely received. Some more junior officials also try their hands at writing criticisms of Admiral Zheng, with mixed results. One particularly infamous memorial is couched so abusively that its author is flogged and fined a month’s salary.

In other news, Sun Chengzong is feeling like it’s high time he retired as Grand Secretary. He’d held onto the post for years beyond when he could’ve stepped down, out of respect for the emperor, but he’s now in his seventies, and keeping the bureaucracy in order is a job for a more vigorous man. He applies for, and receives, permission to return to his hometown of Gaoyang, where he intends to live out his remaining days in peace (although he’s open to consulting unofficially on policy topics).[1]

He is replaced as Grand Secretary by Qian Qianyi, who up until now had been serving as Minister of Rites. Qian’s former post is filled by Kong Zhenyun (孔貞運), an immensely distinguished scholar (he was assessed second nationally out of all jinshi candidates in the forty-seventh year of the Wanli era, which is to say 1619). Minister Kong is also a direct agnatic descendant of Confucius, albeit by a junior line.[2]

Many students, when reading about this era, wonder why Admiral Zheng Zhilong did not attempt more long-term actions like invading Japan itself, going toe-to-toe with the shogun, et cetera. The simplest answer is: that sounds like a lot of work for questionable profit. Raiding Dutch merchant ships was more fun, anyhow. That doesn’t mean that he and his supporters are averse to playing a part in the bloodshed now breaking out in Japan. In the Shimabara domain, the mostly-Christian uprising is eventually suppressed by government forces during the early summer. Occasional resupply runs from Zheng-affiliated captains had allowed the rebels to hold out in several strongholds, and eventually a large portion of the rebels are successfully evacuated by sea. Among those transported from Japan to Dongshan is Amakusa Shirō, a.k.a. Geronimo, the charismatic youth who had led the rebellion. His followers think he can work miracles. The religious makeup of Dongshan is only getting more cosmopolitan by the day.

On their way home, Zheng’s fleet pays a visit to the Ryukyu Kingdom, where the officials, after some prompting, reaffirm their submission to the Great Ming and disclaim any and all loyalty to other sovereigns (particularly to the Japanese). Shō Hō, who has now reigned as king for almost two decades, is not entirely opposed to the move, even if it is negotiated practically at gunpoint; he’s been pushing for more tribute missions with China (an important source of trade for any imperial tributary), and Zheng’s merchant empire looks like a useful partner to have.[3]

Tokugawa Iemitsu is practically seething. Not so much about the Ryukyu thing -- the Ryukyuans paid tribute to the Satsuma daimyos, not to the shogun, and quite frankly he’s got bigger issues than Shimazu Tadatsune (appointed daimyo of the Satsuma domain by Iemitsu’s grandfather) getting a bloody nose. (As it turns out, Tadatsune soon dies and is succeeded by his son Mitsuhisa.) The Shimazu clan are technically loyal, more loyal than some of the crypto-Catholics on Kyushu, but they hold significant power, and right now, the shogun is convinced that his agents need to really bear down hard on any potential sources of dissent. Don’t want another rebellion like the one in Shimabara, which was pretty bad. Don’t want any of the other daimyos getting ideas. Needless to say, his opinions on foreigners, Christians, and traitors are quite negative.

In the Tianqi court, there are celebrations over the birth of Princess Yining. The Emperor now has two surviving sons and one daughter. Daughters obviously are not particularly useful for inheritance purposes, but that’s fine. Nicolas Trigault writes approvingly that the princess is a healthy babe, so far as the medical practitioners can tell, is somewhat quiet but has a clear spark of intelligence in her eyes. Did we mention she’s a newborn infant? Obviously, this is just the Jesuit’s rose-tinted view of the emperor shining through. Still, in this he’s more than a little bit prescient.

The Tianqi Emperor issues a proclamation concerning the creation of eunuchs. A large part of it may have been ghostwritten: the officially published text goes into detail about the Hongwu Emperor and his condemnation of castration and other foreign innovations introduced by the Yuan. The wise patriarch of the dynasty had insisted on standardizing the penal system and had drafted a legal code to guide the people. There was even a section prohibiting people from adopting children from other families and making them eunuchs. Well, it obviously wasn’t enough! From now on, the Tianqi Emperor declares, all castration of children is to be prohibited, and the punishment for doing so increased. Parents who are unable to feed their children are not to send them to Beijing in the hopes they will become an imperial eunuch; the palaces, after all, have scaled down such usage over the past decade and are not presently accepting more. As alternatives, the emperor suggests military service or construction projects to be imminently announced, for those youths unable or unwilling to sit the civil service exams. Minister Dong Kewei is directed to see how the Ministry of Works would be best able to use the manpower.

The plague, which has been killing peasants in Shanxi for quite some time, is now being reported consistently in the villages of Hebei. Travel to some of the worst-affected areas is being restricted, and locals hurry to buy anti-plague remedies of dubious efficacy. The imperial court hosts ceremonies invoking heaven’s power to turn back the plague; only time will tell if heaven responds.



Footnotes
[1] IOTL by 1638 Sun Chengzong had already retired from national politics. In that year, he led his family and personal retainers in a last stand against a Qing military incursion, during which he perished.
[2] He was a real person who existed. The fact that he’s a descendant of Kongzi isn’t really relevant but I thought it was cool.
[3] Shō Hō was previously mentioned in the 1628 update.
 
Yes, no more ball cutting!

Japanese are fuming but there's little they can do atm. I suppose Shogunate will clamp down upon the Shizamu clan which may or may not set a precedent for Ming intervention in traditional sinosphere. But with the plague going on, I have misgivings....
 
I wonder what does the eunuchs have to say about this

Anyway the shogunate should be fine yeah it takes a longer time to crush the Christian rebellions but with Okinawa being under china tributary system again shimazu prestige has gone down so for now one of the more powerful outer daimyos have been humbled.

Still not fun being the shogun though lol
 
It seemed clear to me whoever wrote that memorial was playing very fast and loose with made-up fun facts in order to discredit the institution on bogus but appealing grounds of blaming the Mongols.
 

kholieken

Banned
Yes, no more ball cutting!
Eunuchs in China is more than ball-cutting. Entire genitalia is removed.

Banning child eunuchs would make opportunity for adult eunuchs, especially man who failed exam.

Ming dynasty need to copy Qing Imperial Household Agency to reduce need of eunuchs. Expanding palace woman power is also alternative.
 
Japanese are fuming but there's little they can do atm. I suppose Shogunate will clamp down upon the Shizamu clan which may or may not set a precedent for Ming intervention in traditional sinosphere. But with the plague going on, I have misgivings.

Zheng only confirmed loyalty of Ryoku Kingdom and Emperor was politely informed about dangers of forgein interventionism by major Minister so i don't think there will be Ming intervention in Shogunate over this leaving both free to deal with their internal issues and generally politely ignoring each others.
 
How's Christianity faring out in China under Tianqi? I would expect it to be more popular (though not widespread) in areas where trade with the West is conducted.
 
Eunuchs in China is more than ball-cutting. Entire genitalia is removed.

Banning child eunuchs would make opportunity for adult eunuchs, especially man who failed exam.

Ming dynasty need to copy Qing Imperial Household Agency to reduce need of eunuchs. Expanding palace woman power is also alternative.
That is even more saddening. Makes me wonder why the Chinese didn’t invent catheter.

Yes, expanding on palace women's power, but will there be any revolutionary minded Emperor to challenge this.
 
That is even more saddening. Makes me wonder why the Chinese didn’t invent catheter.

Yes, expanding on palace women's power, but will there be any revolutionary minded Emperor to challenge this.

I mean you would just need revolutionary minded burocrat to push this through, at least because of self interest.
 
Re: eunuchs -- yeah, eunuchs have been a thing in China forever, but the imperial house right now is reframing itself as anti-castration -- when the Hongwu Emperor codified the empire's laws, he standardized the possible punishments to remove older ones like castration and tattooing which had previously been common but which were now seen as barbaric (and of course he accused the Mongols of over-using those older punishments, because of course he would). And there were laws preventing people from illicitly castrating other people's children, which have been smoothly expanded to cover all children, so now -- hopefully -- the range of situations where castration is legally possible should have been greatly reduced.

Will this completely eliminate the practice? Probably not, and there hasn't been too much thought given to exactly how eunuchs are going to be permanently replaced. Even with the emperor's disapproval they still exist ITTL, so it's going to be awhile.

How's Christianity faring out in China under Tianqi? I would expect it to be more popular (though not widespread) in areas where trade with the West is conducted.
Decently well -- it's been awhile since the last wave of official persecution, so they're doing alright -- you'll see a lot more nominal Christians among those who deal with trade, that's correct, plus foreign merchants and missionaries and whatever homebrew religion our boy Geronimo is going to cook up, now that he's survived being executed in Japan.

Eunuchs in China is more than ball-cutting. Entire genitalia is removed.

Banning child eunuchs would make opportunity for adult eunuchs, especially man who failed exam.

Ming dynasty need to copy Qing Imperial Household Agency to reduce need of eunuchs. Expanding palace woman power is also alternative.
That is even more saddening. Makes me wonder why the Chinese didn’t invent catheter.

Yes, expanding on palace women's power, but will there be any revolutionary minded Emperor to challenge this.
I mean you would just need revolutionary minded burocrat to push this through, at least because of self interest.
...y'all have just given me an idea. Long-term, but I'll figure out how to work it in.
 
1639
Cavalry_procession.jpg

A diplomatic procession led by Joseon officials

In the parts of the world that aren’t China, things are happening.

Pope Urban VIII, he of the anti-tobacco papal bull, has just published another papal bull prohibiting slavery. It’s a nice gesture which is likely to have about the same long-term impact as the tobacco ban.

England, Scotland, and Ireland are tearing each other apart in war. The causes are complex; religion, monarchy, freedom. English merchants are still present in east Asia, particularly in India, sometimes in the same circles as the Dutch -- just because there’s war at home doesn’t mean there isn’t money to be made.

Speaking of the Dutch, they’re complying with the Tokugawa demands to limit their activities in Japan. Consequently, they’re some of the only Europeans in Japan right now. They do have to withdraw many of their personnel and especially their families -- they are transported by ship to Batavia. The ships are sometimes harassed by Zheng’s privateers. It should be noted that the Dutch ships are mostly capable of taking care of themselves, especially now that they’re on their guard. Dutch fleets win naval victories against the Spanish, back in European waters, and oust the Portuguese from their foothold at Trincomalee. For the East India Company, pirate raids are pretty low-priority compared to all the cool stuff they’re doing right now.

Speaking of the Spanish and Portuguese, while the two kingdoms have been in personal union for a century, tensions are rising back home. Their overseas colonies (including the Spanish foothold at the northern tip of Dongshan) have gotten a little bit mingled over the years, but people are starting to get nervous when considering the future. Nobody’s looking forward to the day when, for example, an armada out of the Philippines might try raiding Macau.[1]

That’s about as close as European affairs have gotten to affecting China so far.

Nobody in Beijing is thinking much of Europe, just as most people in Europe are not thinking much of China (save, perhaps, some very enthusiastic young Jesuits, such as Martino Martini, who has just been made a priest). No, Beijing is mostly interested in a recent visit from one of its tributaries. King Injo of Joseon, unusually, has made an appearance in person. And he brings with him an emissary from the Northern Yuan.

The king of Joseon and the khan of the Northern Yuan have quietly been coordinating their campaigns against the remnants of the Later Jin. Ajige, who has thus far eliminated most of his competitors and thus finds himself with precious few bannermen to resist the invasion, flees further north into even more marginal areas of the steppe. Joseon’s armies advance in furtherance of the dream that the lands of Balhae shall once more be theirs. The Northern Yuan are less interested in land than in men; they had taken substantial losses during Yuan Chonghuan’s campaigns against them, and the low population densities of steppe nomad societies are poorly able to absorb such losses. More men must be acquired, whether by adoption or enslavement.[2]

Now that the military forces of both polities have finally met -- their enemies are on the run -- they have decided to make their...relationship, for lack of a better word, public. So Injo of Joseon and his counterpart from the Northern Yuan (not Ejei, that much is clear from the chronicles, but probably a close relative) bring lavish tribute, and bow very low, and explain that Yuan Chonghuan’s death was deeply unfortunate, even though they were technically at war, and that they respect the man a great deal, and that they hope they will be allowed to honor his memory -- since, of course, it would do everybody good to join hands in friendship so that they can deal with the real enemy, which is, of course, the Later Jin -- and also being a tributary of the emperor is nice and please don’t get mad and kill us.

The Tianqi Emperor, stone-faced, gets up and walks out of the audience hall. The remainder of the tributaries’ visit is handled by intermediaries. (Minister Dong understands the emperor’s reaction. He, himself, is a little bit annoyed that these foreigners have come in and hogged all the attention. He was about to announce the first of his infrastructure projects, starting with an effort to dredge the harbor of Hangzhou.)

Eventually, a deal is hashed out. (It helps a little that the Northern Yuan and the Joseon have done their best with this year’s tribute.) The Northern Yuan will pay a substantial indemnity, spread out over the next decade, and will officially acknowledge the suzerainty of the emperor in Beijing. In exchange, the Ming will defend the Northern Yuan against foreign invaders and will take no further action against them for any past hostility. Violations of this agreement will, of course, be met with swift retribution. The Northern Yuan will send a number of hostages (technically, they are honored guests being hosted at the Ming court for purposes of education / networking / etc) to live in Beijing. The Joseon state will be personally responsible for any violation of the agreement on the part of the Northern Yuan. And Ming armies will officially join the campaign against Ajige, with further military cooperation to be decided at a future date.

The Ming court does not offer particularly lavish gifts to its tributaries this year. Relations will probably be a bit frosty for a while. However, before the Northern Yuan emissary leaves, a servant presents him with an unusual item -- it is a wooden horse, hand-carved, unadorned but of unusually fine craftsmanship.

The emissary, once the item’s context is explained, solemnly accepts the gift with every indication of respect. Things could have gone a lot worse.



Footnotes
[1] Everything in Europe is happening more or less as it did IOTL. Charles I of England, Scotland, and Ireland is in big trouble, the Iberian Union is starting to fray (with many Portuguese nobles plotting revolution), and the Dutch, despite having to deal with Admiral Zheng’s men, are doing pretty well on the naval front. Also, the Pope is trying to ban slavery. And tobacco.
[2] This is a common theme of historical steppe nomad societies IOTL. Men being admitted as foster-brothers or slaves, women typically being made concubines or wives -- not pleasant, when you start to think about the details, but you can see how such patterns would develop. Incidentally, George R. R. Martin’s depiction of the Dothraki has many flaws, but this is perhaps one of the greatest -- his Dothraki do little more than kill, on a scale that should be unsustainable in a steppe nomad population, and do not seem to absorb smaller tribes or do anything to preserve their population levels. Indeed, the Dothraki appear united around the personal rule of the khals, with little in the way of cultural or political institutions holding them together into long-term polities. Steppe nomads may have been relatively decentralized compared to sedentary agrarian empires, but they engaged in trade and diplomacy when it suited them, not just rampaging in senseless violence. For all his snark about “Aragorn’s tax policy,” George R. R. Martin owes a lot to Tolkien and his actual knowledge of how fictional and historical societies worked.
 
Last edited:
1640
389px-Portrait_of_John%2C_Duke_of_Braganza_c._1630_%28The_Royal_Castle_in_Warsaw%29.png

John, Duke of Braganza (later to be John IV of Portugal), a person who is somehow affecting events in China circa 1640

Wang Wei, the courtesan-turned-poet, is on a trip to Kaifeng (for Buddhist reasons) when she is attacked by a street gang. Fortunately, a young man comes charging to the rescue (or so say the storybook versions of this tale). His name is Gao Xuan; he is the scion of one of the prominent families in the Kaifeng Jewish community.[1]

Qin Liangyu, whose bannermen helped put down the Yellow Tiger in 1636, is mostly retired at this point (although she is occasionally asked for advice in suppressing other rebels, including the “False Tigers”). But she’s very happy to learn that her friend Wang Wei was saved from harm. Thus, she does Gao Xuan a favor by writing him a letter of recommendation so that he might travel to Beijing and make a name for himself, as is his desire.

In Beijing, Nicolas Trigault has finished his latest project: a translation of the play Mingfeng ji, “The Phoenix’s Cry,” from Chinese into French. It is the first work of Chinese theater to be translated to a European language, and will soon inspire European adaptations of varying levels of quality.[2] Certainly, the musical interludes are very likely a French invention.

Meanwhile, in one of the small twists which prove the world is smaller than one thinks, events in Portugal have spilled over into war. The Portuguese nation has, for years, seethed under the Spanish yoke. Though they accepted Philip II (who did have a decent claim to the throne) and tolerated Philip III (who was something of a nonentity), resentment has slowly grown during the reign of Philip IV (the Planet King, whose lands stretch from one end of the world to the other).

The Portuguese and Spanish kingdoms were joined in personal union, but not politically or economically. Merchants who traveled from Lisbon to Madrid (or from any part of the Portuguese colonial empire to the Spanish -- or among the nominally distinct crowns of Spain) faced logistical hurdles almost as bad as going from, say, Lisbon to London.[3]

Speaking of London, the personal union between Spain and Portugal has wrecked a lot of Portugal’s foreign relations, including the severing of its centuries-old alliance with England. True, the Portuguese do enjoy the benefit of not having to fight Spain anymore -- theoretically their colonies should be cooperating instead of competing -- but in practice, the monarchs who rule Spain have largely neglected the Portuguese parts of the empire. This is why the Dutch have been able to take bits out of Portuguese India.

Thus, in the later months of 1640, a small group of Portuguese noblemen put the finishing touches on their conspiracy to oust the Spanish from their kingdom. They declare for John, the Duke of Braganza, who accepts the throne. The conspiracy is successful, although fighting between Spain and Portugal will continue for many years to come.

António Teles da Silva, Captain-Major of the Portuguese Indian Armada, is among the conspirators.[4] He had found his commission extended several times and has had to watch in frustration as the Dutch continued to make inroads on the Portuguese colonial empire. He’s appealed several times to Sebastián Hurtado de Corcuera, (Spanish) Governor-General of the Philippines, for assistance. Hurtado, a notoriously prickly man, refused point-blank.[5]

So, when a bunch of people in Portugal are busy assassinating Spanish nobles and raising men to fight the inevitable war, Captain-Major Teles is leading a bunch of Portuguese to the Spanish colony on the tip of Dongshan, which they capture after a bit of sharp fighting.

Governor-General Hurtado, from his base in the Philippines, is furious when he finds out. (So are plenty of other people in Spain. When Hurtado is eventually recalled, he finds himself standing trial for negligence in allowing the loss of their outpost on Dongshan.[6])

But how, exactly, did the Portuguese under Teles succeed? The answer is -- well, obviously, it’s Admiral Zheng again. According to rumor (and this is never quite confirmed), the Admiral had heard whispers of the Spanish-Portuguese disputes and had all but invited Teles to invade, giving him comprehensive information on the fortifications of the Spanish outpost. In return, Captain-Major Teles (in the name of the Portuguese crown) recognizes Zheng Zhilong as “Lord Protector of Formosa” (although by now, the Chinese name of “Dongshan” is starting to see increasingly common use in learned European circles). Zheng’s men will protect the Portuguese on Dongshan from Spanish reprisals, but will also have access to the land near the outpost for things like mineral exploration. (There’s gold in them thar hills.)

Obviously, there will be repercussions. The Portuguese are celebrating their little coup. The imperial court in Beijing will probably have something to say about everything that happened. And the Spanish in the Philippines are bracing for what might end up being another war.[7] If there’s one group of people who can be said to be happy with all this chaos, it’s probably the Japanese -- but then, the formerly dormant Komagatake volcano just blew its top, and now the crops are failing all over Japan.[8]

One thing’s for sure. Things are far from boring right now.



Footnotes
[1] IOTL Gao Xuan made his name in 1642 by repeatedly diving into floodwaters in order to retrieve part of the community’s Torah scroll. Why was Kaifeng flooded in 1642? Because someone breached the Yellow River dikes during Li Zicheng’s siege of the city. A lot of people died and the Kaifeng Jews lost pretty much everything. That isn’t happening ITTL!
[2] See the 1630 update. To recap, “The Phoenix’s Cry” is a history play where a virtuous character gets executed because an enemy surreptitiously adds his name to another man’s death warrant. This is in contrast with OTL, where the first Chinese play to be translated into a European language was “The Orphan of Zhao,” a history play where a virtuous character gets executed because an enemy surreptitiously adds his name to another man’s death warrant.
[3] I’m exaggerating here -- the years have smoothed over some differences -- but de jure, Portugal is still a separate country and besides the king himself, there is very little holding the Iberian Union together.
[4] Everything I’ve described until now about Portugal, Spain, and the House of Braganza is pretty much how it went IOTL. António Teles da Silva was one of the Forty Conspirators who supported John of Braganza. IOTL, though, it appears he was back in Portugal when the shit hit the fan.
[5] Up until now, Hurtado has become notorious as the guy who led soldiers into a church to arrest a murderer who had been trying to claim sanctuary, then exiling the Archbishop of Manila for daring to criticize him. Yes, this is all OTL.
[6] IOTL the Spanish held onto their part of Formosa until the Dutch captured it in 1642. Hurtado had made a bunch of enemies, who had him arrested a few years later for failing to prevent this.
[7] IOTL Zheng Zhilong’s son, Zheng Chenggong, better known as Koxinga, was outright threatening to invade the Philippines, and might’ve even gotten away with it had he not suddenly fallen ill and died in 1662.
[8] The Komagatake eruption happened IOTL and led to years of famine.
 
Well Zheng is again making independent plays, but as long as he is successful and his actions benefit Ming it could be excused. Well as long as he doesn't involve the Empire in major war but then again...

[7] IOTL Zheng Zhilong’s son, Zheng Chenggong, better known as Koxinga, was outright threatening to invade the Philippines, and might’ve even gotten away with it had he not suddenly fallen ill and died in 1662.

If this is within Ming Empires capabilities (by which i mean its within limits of short and painless war) and given the fact that both Spanish and Portuguese are busy killing each other's a little intervention on Portuguese side wouldn't hurt . This could in Grand picture of thing excuse Zhengs independent action.
 
Last edited:
It cracks me up that your initial description of John IV was as "a person who is somehow affecting events in China".

Admiral Zheng strikes again! Honestly "pulling a Zheng" has  got to be a saying by know, at least among the castle staff.
 
[2] See the 1630 update. To recap, “The Phoenix’s Cry” is a history play where a virtuous character gets executed because an enemy surreptitiously adds his name to another man’s death warrant. This is in contrast with OTL, where the first Chinese play to be translated into a European language was “The Orphan of Zhao,” a history play where a virtuous character gets executed because an enemy surreptitiously adds his name to another man’s death warrant.
Ha.
 
Top